The Headless Horseman, Terror of Sleepy Hollow Enchanted, 232/204 Kicking off our list of the most valuable Whispers in the Well cards is this incredible atmospheric, beautifully illustrated Headless Horseman card
This was one of those cards that a lot of decks were on the edge of playing, either because they couldn't quite get threshold reliably or they didn't want to splash one of the colors, inviting them to play a high-risk but high-reward game with their mana bases that both cost them games and won them games they had little right to win
Prophet of Kruphix First Printed: 2013-SEP Banned: 2016-JAN Prophet of Kruphix creates a gameplay pattern where the controller of the card can interact and meaningfully play during each other players turns
Jace must have been doing his daily stretches, because boy, is he flexible
The deck also contains some great reprints, like Three Visits and Farewell, while Yuna is a great Commander in her own right
This is the card Doomfall wishes it was